Substack: Simple newsletter with paid subscription
Substack is the simplest way to start a newsletter with paid subscriptions. Free to start with 10% revenue share on paid subscriptions. Built-in discovery and reader app.
About
Substack is the simplest way to start a newsletter with paid subscriptions. Free to start with 10% revenue share on paid subscriptions. Built-in discovery and reader app.
Our Take on Substack
Verdict: Substack is the easiest way to start a newsletter and get paid for writing. It's free to start, and its reader network (recommendations, Notes, the app) brings in subscribers you wouldn't find alone. You pay for that with 10% of your paid revenue, forever. Writers who reach meaningful income usually do the maths and move to beehiiv or Ghost.
What it really costs
Substack is free until you charge readers. Then:
- Substack takes 10% of paid-subscription revenue
- Stripe takes 2.9% + $0.30 per payment, plus recurring-billing fees
All in, that's about 13–16% of gross revenue. On $2,000 a month in subscriptions, roughly $260–320 goes to fees every month.
Break-even points: beehiiv's Lite plan ($49/month, 0% take rate) is cheaper once you earn more than about $490/month. Ghost's Publisher plan ($29/month on annual billing, 0% Ghost fees) breaks even even sooner.
Why writers still choose Substack
- Discovery. Recommendations from other Substack writers and the Substack app are real growth channels, and you lose most of them when you leave.
- No setup. Writing, publishing, payments and the web archive work immediately, with no themes or domains to configure.
- Podcasts, video and chat sit in the same place as the newsletter.
Where it falls short
- The 10% never shrinks. It's the same cut at $500/month and at $50,000/month.
- Limited control. Design customisation, custom automations and data tools are basic compared with beehiiv, Kit or Ghost.
- Platform reputation. Substack's 2024 content-moderation controversy prompted some writers to leave on principle. Consider whether the platform's brand matters to your audience.
Choose Substack if
- You're starting from zero and want readers from the network
- You write, and don't want to manage tools, themes or automation
- Paid revenue is small or uncertain
Avoid it if
- Paid revenue is already above about $500/month. The fee costs more than a paid platform would
- You want custom design, automations or sponsorship tooling
- You want to own your stack. Look at Ghost
Compare: Substack vs beehiiv and Ghost vs Substack. More in email & newsletter tools.
Key Features
Pricing
Pros & Cons
Pros
- check_circleVery simple
- check_circleBuilt-in audience
- check_circleFree to start
- check_circleReader app
Cons
- cancel10% fee on revenue
- cancelLimited customization
- cancelBasic analytics
Alternatives
* May earn commission at no cost to you